"Mendelssohn Favorites Offer Precision, Grace and Grit"
The New York Times, January 30, 2009.
Yes, I'm playing catch-up again. sigh.
As a reader, I always enjoyed those occasions when a composer's birthday, or some other celebration, brought one of those record-roundup features in The New York Times, for which each of the critics listed his or her favorite related CDs. As a Times contributor, I've found it just as much fun to take part, though selecting just five (or fewer) discs to represent a composer or style is grueling.
Oddly, though, in the case of Mendelssohn it was very, very easy to pick five recordings; it was winnowing it down to four that proved tricky. Here's what I included, with handy e-tail links provided:
VIOLIN CONCERTO IN E MINOR Nathan Milstein, violinist; New York Philharmonic, conducted by Bruno Walter (with other concertos, other performers; Sony Classical 64459, MP3 download; Naxos 8.110977, CD).
(Sony MP3, via Amazon; Naxos CD, via Amazon UK, not available in the U.S. and possibly newly deleted)
SYMPHONY NO. 3, ‘A MIDSUMMER NIGHT’S DREAM’ OVERTURE AND INCIDENTAL MUSIC Jennifer Vyvyan and Marion Lowe, sopranos; Female Chorus of the Royal Opera House; London Symphony, conducted by Peter Maag (Decca 466 990-2; CD).
(ArkivMusic, Barnes & Noble)
SYMPHONY NO. 5 Berlin Philharmonic, conducted by Lorin Maazel (with Franck’s Symphony played by the Berlin Radio Symphony; Deutsche Grammophon 449 720-2; CD).
(ArkivMusic, Barnes & Noble)
PIANO TRIOS NOS. 1, 2 Trio Wanderer (Harmonia Mundi France HMC 901961; CD).
(ArkivMusic, Barnes & Noble)
The two symphony recordings were no-brainers; those are among my favorite orchestral discs, period. A CD of the two piano trios was also vital, and Wanderer had the best mix of grace and gusto far as I was concerned. Picking a single recording of the violin concerto was the most daunting prospect; the four versions I mentioned parenthetically (Kreisler, Campoli, Hahn and Jansen) were the ones that hung me up most, as did the fabulous David Oistrakh recording with the Philadelphia Orchestra. But then I came back around to Milstein's version with Walter, and I knew I was finished.
Had there been a fifth slot, as has been the case most times we've run these surveys, I'd likely have awarded it to Giuseppe Sinopoli's Deutsche Grammophon recording of the Symphony No. 4 ("Italian"). But on revisiting that CD, and putting it head-to-head with Maazel's "Reformation," I realized that not only was the latter more compelling, but that the real reason I've cherished that Sinopoli disc is its completely absorbing version of Schubert's Symphony No. 8.
An enjoyable exercise, overall—though truth be told, I've have enjoyed it more had my fingers not detached from my higher cognitive functions for a brief second, causing me to refer to a "Spring" symphony when I quite obviously meant the "Scottish" symphony, about which I'd just written almost an entire paragraph directly above. To clarify a further point, the version of the Milstein/Walter recording that can be downloaded for less than $3 at Amazon is not a CD, but just the recording of the concerto; the other half of that disc is the Beethoven concerto with Joseph Szigeti, and the entire "CD" will run you just under $6.